Let me start by saying I've tried A LOT of dog poop bags over the years. From flimsy dollar store options to 'premium' brands that still managed to leak, I thought I'd seen it all - until I discovered Doggy Do Good.

The good stuff first: These are hands-down the thickest, most reliable compostable bags I've used. My 70lb Labrador's 'deposits' are no match for these sturdy green warriors. The extra width at the opening is genius - no more awkward hand-wiggling to avoid... well, you know. They tie easily with either a simple twist or proper knot.

What really sold me was the eco-cred. As someone who cringes adding plastic to landfills, the USDA Certified Biobased certification and compostability (where facilities allow) gives me peace of mind. They've held up through rain, snow, and my dog's most... ambitious creations.

Now the not-so-great: Like several reviewers mentioned, there appears to have been a quality slip in early 2024. My last box had bags that tore way too easily - nothing ruins a walk like surprise poop confetti! The company was responsive with replacements though.

Pro tip: If you get a batch where the printing/box looks different than product photos, test carefully. The good news? Recent orders seem back to normal quality.

At about $0.10 per bag (standard size), they're pricier than basic plastic but cheaper than many 'eco' competitors. For clean pickups without environmental guilt (and strong enough for Great Danes!), these remain my top pick - just watch for those occasional bad batches.