Let me start by saying I've installed this exact Moen soap holder twice - once before my bathroom remodel and again after. That chrome finish? Gorgeous when new, but my first one did develop rust after years of shower steam (hence the replacement).

The 6.25" square design fits perfectly in my compact vintage bathroom. That recessed mount is genius - no more elbow-bumping accidents! The plastic tray keeps soap from sliding around, though I wish it had slightly rounded edges (current version feels sharp).

Installation was a breeze... if you remember to order the BR587/BR588 clamp separately (Moen whyyy?!). Pro tip: The metal feels thinner than my original 1960s version - time will tell if it holds up as well.

What surprised me most? How that mirror-like chrome actually brightens my shower corner. It's like having an extra light source! Just be prepared to wipe water spots regularly to maintain the shine.

The included template made positioning foolproof, though you absolutely need wood backing for secure mounting. Two screws later, and voilà - instant upgrade that makes my daily showers feel more luxurious.

Final verdict? A stylish, functional piece that elevates any bathroom... provided you budget extra for that essential clamp and don't mind some occasional maintenance.