Let me start by saying this book is a rollercoaster of emotions. From the moment I opened 'The Midnight Library', I was hooked. The concept of exploring different versions of one's life based on past choices is both terrifying and exhilarating.

The writing flows beautifully - I finished it in two sittings because I physically couldn't put it down. Matt Haig has this incredible ability to make you laugh on one page and tear up on the next. The scene where Nora first enters the library gave me literal chills.

What really struck me was how personal it felt. Like many readers, I've had those 'what if' moments about my own life choices. Seeing Nora live out these alternate realities made me reflect on my own paths not taken, but also appreciate my current life more.

The character development is masterful. Nora starts as someone you might pity, but through her journey becomes someone you genuinely root for. Mrs. Elm is that wise mentor we all wish we had in our lives.

Now for some real talk - yes, the ending is somewhat predictable (I called it about halfway through), but that doesn't diminish its power one bit. Sometimes we need stories that confirm our hopes rather than subvert them.

Practical note: This isn't a light beach read despite its page-turning quality. Have some tissues ready, and maybe don't read it during your lunch break at work (speaking from experience).

Minor critique: Some of the alternate lives feel a bit rushed, and there's one particular career path Nora explores that stretched my suspension of disbelief. But these are small quibbles in an otherwise phenomenal book.

Final verdict? This book stayed with me for weeks after finishing it. It's the kind of story that changes how you see your own life - not through grand revelations, but through quiet, persistent nudges toward self-acceptance.