When my friend first showed me 'I Think I Don't Remember,' they were cracking up. I thought, 'Okay, maybe it's an inside joke or just takes a second to click.' But after buying it? Total letdown.

The humor feels stuck in another era—like finding your dad's old meme folder. What might've been quirky years ago now just falls flat. I kept waiting for that 'aha!' moment, but it never came.

Worst part? The more I tried to force myself to like it (because hey, money spent), the more awkward it felt. Like laughing at a funeral because someone told you to. Some jokes just don't age well, and this one fossilized.

Pro tip: If you're buying nostalgia humor, at least make sure it's YOUR nostalgia. Otherwise you'll be stuck with a conversation piece that kills conversations.