Harry Turtledove's Drive to the East: Settling Accounts, Book 2 is a masterclass in alternate history. The way he reimagines a world where the Confederate States of America remain independent and wage war against the United States is nothing short of brilliant. The book picks up in 1943, with the CSA led by a Hitler-esque demagogue, and the tension is palpable from page one.
One of the standout features of this series is Turtledove's use of real historical figures in entirely new contexts. It's fascinating to see how their lives and decisions diverge from what we know. The social tensions and complexities of the characters make this more than just a war story—it's a deep dive into what could have been.
The pacing in this installment is a significant improvement over some of Turtledove's earlier works. The North begins to make strategic inroads against the South, and the narrative feels more dynamic. However, I did find some scenes repetitive, especially with characters like Granny and Dr. O'Doul doing the same things over and over. It reminded me of M*A*S*H, where the repetition was part of the charm but could also feel tedious.
The portrayal of the Negro holocaust in the making is both harrowing and gripping. It's a stark reminder of how easily history could have taken a darker turn. On a lighter note, I loved the subtle nods to baseball history, like using Foxx and Greenberg as soldiers' passwords—a delightful touch for fans of the sport.
While this book can stand alone, I highly recommend starting from The Great War: American Front to fully appreciate the depth of Turtledove's world-building. Some plotlines follow WWII templates too closely, but overall, this is a thrilling read that keeps you hooked until the last page.
If you're a fan of alternate history or just love a well-crafted war saga, Drive to the East is worth every minute. Just be prepared for some heavy themes and occasional déjà vu moments.