I've been wearing the Rockport Men's Taylor Waterproof Wingtip Oxford for a few weeks now, and overall, I'm impressed. The waterproof feature (Hydro Shield Technology) really works—I’ve walked through puddles and rainy streets, and my feet stayed completely dry. The genuine leather upper looks sharp and is easy to wipe clean, which is great for someone like me who doesn’t want to fuss over maintenance.

The comfort level is close to that of a tennis shoe, which surprised me. They’re lightweight and flexible, making them ideal for long days on my feet. However, I do agree with some reviewers that the cushioning could be better. My last pair from another brand had plusher insoles, but these Rockports feel more durable, so it’s a trade-off.

Fit-wise, they run true to size (I ordered my usual 10.5), but I’ve heard mixed reviews about width. Some say they run narrow, so if you have wider feet, you might want to double-check sizing or opt for a wide width if available.

The style is classic but not overly formal—perfect for business casual or even dressed-down office wear. My only gripe? The toe box isn’t as sleek as I’d like; it could be a tad pointier for a sharper look.

One thing to watch out for: A reviewer mentioned receiving what seemed like a returned pair sold as new. I didn’t have that issue, but it’s worth inspecting your shoes upon arrival.

Overall, these are solid shoes—great for wet weather, comfortable enough for all-day wear, and built to last. Just make sure you nail the sizing!