Let me start by saying these Subaru OEM all-weather floor mats are a game-changer for Legacy Outback and Baja owners. The precise fit is absolutely perfect - they hug every contour of my 2004 Outback's footwells like they were molded there (because they were!).

The deep tray design is brilliant for containing muddy boots or spilled coffee. I've put them through a Pacific Northwest winter, and they've caught everything from pine needles to melted snow without letting anything seep through to the carpet below.

However, I do agree with other reviewers about the material feeling slightly flimsy for the price point. While they're durable enough for daily use, I wouldn't call them heavy-duty. The surface can be a bit slippery when wet too - my work boots have slid around on rainy days.

The textured Subaru logo looks sharp though, maintaining that OEM aesthetic we all love. After six months of use, mine still look brand new after a quick hose-down.

Bottom line? If you want perfect fitment and decent protection without going full hardcore rubber mat, these are your best bet. Just don't expect them to be as rugged as some aftermarket options at this price.