Let me start by saying I've installed this exact Moen soap holder twice now—once in my old bathroom and again after a remodel. The chrome finish is undeniably eye-catching, reflecting light beautifully and giving my shower a polished hotel-like vibe. It's like upgrading from a motel soap dish to a luxury spa accessory.

The recessed design is genius for small bathrooms (like my vintage 1960s setup). No more knocking elbows on protruding soap dishes! The included plastic tray keeps my bar soap high and dry, though the edges are sharper than I'd prefer—almost gave me a papercut during installation.

Installation was straightforward... once I realized the crucial Donner clamp wasn't included. Rookie mistake! Had to pause my weekend project to order BR587 separately. Pro tip: Add that $10 clamp to your cart immediately. The actual mounting took minutes with just two screws into wood backing.

I do notice the metal feels thinner than older models—time will tell if it holds up like the original that lasted decades in my rental property. That said, the limited lifetime warranty provides peace of mind. After six months of daily use in our humid bathroom, zero signs of corrosion or wear.

The 6.25" square size fits standard shower spaces perfectly without overwhelming smaller walls. It blends seamlessly with other chrome fixtures while adding that subtle grab-bar safety feature older relatives appreciate. Cleaning is effortless thanks to the removable tray—no more gunky soap residue buildup!

Would I buy again? Absolutely, but only after warning friends about the separate clamp requirement. For under $30 (plus clamp), it elevates basic showers with commercial-grade durability and timeless style.