Okay, let me start by saying I’ve tried a LOT of brow products—pencils, gels, powders—you name it. But the Benefit Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Fiber Pencil? It’s a game-changer. The silk cotton tree fibers actually make my sparse brows look fuller without that weird, drawn-on effect. It’s like magic in a tiny tube.

First application had me hooked. The texture is perfect—not too waxy, not too dry. I just swipe it lightly through my brows, and the blended powder particles give this soft, natural depth. No harsh lines, no drama. And the best part? It stays put. I’ve worn it through workouts (sweaty mess included) and rainy days, and it doesn’t budge.

Now, fair warning: the pencil is a bit fragile. I learned the hard way not to sharpen it aggressively—it snapped once, and I nearly cried over the wasted product. But once you get the hang of gentle sharpening (or just use it as-is for a softer look), it’s fine.

Color payoff is great too. I use shade 2.5, and while it looked slightly darker in the tube than expected, it blends out beautifully. Even my clumsy hands can’t mess this up—perfect for beginners or anyone who hates spending ages on their brows.

Final verdict? If you want brows that look naturally full but don’t have time for fussy techniques, this pencil is worth every penny. Just…be nice to it when sharpening.