Okay, let me just start by saying these Reef sandals are EVERYTHING! I've been living in them since they arrived.
First off - the comfort level is insane. The footbed feels like walking on clouds, and I wore them for a full day at an amusement park with zero foot fatigue. That never happens with new sandals!
The Velcro straps make them super adjustable, though fair warning - they did rub a bit the first couple wears (but what new sandals don't?). After breaking them in, they fit like a dream.
I love how versatile they are - dressed them up with sundresses and down with shorts. The tan color goes with literally everything in my wardrobe.
Bonus points for being water-friendly! Walked through puddles and wet pool decks without slipping. The lug sole gives great traction.
Sizing tip: They run true to size for me (I'm normally a 7 and got a 7), but if you're between sizes maybe size down slightly as they do stretch a bit with wear.
Only downside? Now I want them in every color! Reef really nailed it with these - cute AND comfortable? Yes please!