First off, these shoes are *adorable*. The vintage brogue style with a chunky heel gives off major retro vibes, and they pair perfectly with both dress slacks and jeans. I’ve gotten so many compliments already!

The heel height (about 2 inches) is just right—enough to give a little lift without killing my feet. As someone who’s usually in flats, I was surprised by how comfortable these are for all-day wear. The toe box is roomy, which is a lifesaver for my wide feet.

BUT… there are some quirks. The laces feel cheap and are annoyingly short—I’ll probably replace them. Also, the left heel started creaking after just two wears? Super awkward in quiet office settings. And yeah, that synthetic smell when they arrived? Not great.

For the price, they’re decent if you can overlook the flaws. Just maybe don’t gift them unless you swap the laces first!