Let me start by saying these sandals are STUNNING in person. The braided raffia upper gives off that effortless boho-chic vibe that instantly elevates any summer outfit. I wore them to a garden wedding with a flowy maxi dress and received so many compliments!

The cushioned footbed is genuinely comfortable for all-day wear - I danced for hours without the usual 'flat sandal regret'. They're noticeably more supportive than typical flip-flops, though not quite as plush as orthopedic sandals.

Now the elephant in the room: sizing is WILD. I'm normally a solid size 8, but these felt like I was wearing my little sister's shoes. My toes kept peeking out the front! After reading other reviews, I exchanged for a 7.5 which fits perfectly. Pro tip: SIZE DOWN at least half a size unless you have particularly wide feet.

The materials debate is interesting - while they're marketed as leather, the sole is definitely synthetic (a disappointment at this price point). However, the upper straps do feel like quality raffia and leather. If you have fabric sensitivities, beware.

Final verdict? These are my new go-to 'fancy flats' for events where heels would be torture. Just be prepared to play sizing roulette - maybe order two sizes to compare. At $20-30, they're priced fairly for the style but don't expect luxury materials throughout.