Let me start by saying—this book wrecked me in the best way possible. As the finale to Jessie Gussman's Baxter Boys series, 'Second Chance With You' delivers ALL the emotional gut-punches while wrapping up loose ends beautifully. Ben and Riley's story? Chef's kiss.

The Good Stuff: The slow-burn chemistry between mechanic Ben and Riley had me squealing into my pillow. Their history—childhood friends torn apart by family interference and betrayal—is painfully relatable. Gussman nails the 'blue-collar romance' vibe with garage scenes that smell like motor oil and vulnerability. And can we talk about Gram’s subplot? I sobbed actual tears during Ben’s reunion with his long-lost brothers.

Reality Check: If you hate miscommunication tropes, buckle up—Riley’s past lie is a DOOZY (though her redemption arc is worth it). Also, heads-up: the audiobook narrator’s flat character voices might make you switch to Kindle.

Secret MVP: The biblical references woven throughout aren’t preachy—they add this quiet depth that made scenes like Ben praying over his broken-down truck unexpectedly powerful.

As someone who DEVOURED all four Baxter books, this ranks top-tier for its messy, hopeful take on second chances. Pro tip: Have tissues ready for Chapter 17. Just trust me.