Let me start by saying, this book had me in a chokehold from Chapter 3 onwards. Lisa Jewell masterfully crafts a story that's less about the 'whodunit' (you'll figure that out early) and more about the devastating aftermath of loss.

The character development is phenomenal - especially Laurel, the grieving mother. I found myself yelling at her choices one minute, then weeping for her the next. That scene where she first meets Floyd? Chills. The way Jewell writes human connection feels so painfully real.

Now the controversial part: yes, the mystery element is light. If you're expecting Agatha Christie-level twists, adjust your expectations. But what you get instead is this raw, psychological exploration of how families fracture after tragedy. The multiple POVs add delicious layers - though I'll admit Poppy's chapters had me sleeping with the lights on for days.

My biggest critique? The ending felt rushed. After 300 pages of exquisite tension, the resolution came like a deflating balloon. I needed more closure for Laurel! Also trigger warning: some scenes involving Noelle are genuinely disturbing in a 'can't-unsee-it' way.

Perfect for: readers who enjoy character-driven dramas with dark edges, fans of Liane Moriarty's style but craving something grittier.

Skip if: You need constant plot twists or can't handle morally ambiguous characters making questionable decisions.

Final verdict? 4/5 stars - loses one star for the abrupt ending but gains infinite points for making me cancel weekend plans to finish it in one sitting.