First off, let me just say—these shoes are STUNNING. The two-tone leather and those classic saddle oxford vibes? Chef’s kiss. Johnston & Murphy never disappoints with their dignified aesthetic.

BUT. The sizing drama is real. I trusted Amazon’s ‘size recommendation’ (based on ‘millions of reviews’—lol, there was literally ONE review for this style). Went with a 13 instead of my usual 12… and had to return them unworn. Heartbreaking.

On the bright side: the waterproof construction feels legit, the linings are stupid soft, and that removable cushioned footbed? *chef’s kiss again*. Also, shoutout to the rubber sole—durable but not clunky.

PSA: If you snag these, maybe size up? Fellow reviewer said their size 11 ran tight too. Still… if they fit? Absolute wardrobe heroes. (Just wish they came in a lighter color option—*side-eyes Johnston & Murphy*.)