Okay, let me just say - these shoes are LEGIT. I was nervous about buying dress shoes online without trying them first, but wow was I wrong to doubt.
The first wear was a bit snug (like all good leather shoes should be), but after just two outings they molded to my feet like Cinderella's glass slipper. Now they're literally the most comfortable dress shoes in my closet.
The leather quality? *chef's kiss* It takes polish so well that I got a mirror shine that would make a Marine drill sergeant proud. I've lost count of how many compliments I get every time I wear these bad boys to the office.
Pro tip: Don't panic if you notice some imperfect stitching or polish marks - mine came with a tiny gap near the sole and one shoe had uneven polish. Turns out that's just part of their handmade charm (and honestly, no one notices but you).
Final verdict: If you're hesitating on pulling the trigger - DON'T. These are worth every penny. I'd wear them every day if society wouldn't judge me for it.