Let me start by saying these Hanes boxers are like the reliable old friend in your underwear drawer. The cotton is *stupid soft* – like, 'why-didn't-I-switch-sooner' soft. I've worn them through 8-hour workdays and weekend Netflix marathons, and they never ride up or get that weird bunching thing some boxers do.

The waistband deserves its own praise track. Unlike those elastic bands that leave red marks (we've all been there), this one disappears against your skin. Major win for guys who hate that 'sausage casing' feeling.

Now, the elephant in the room – *that button*. Picture this: a random button positioned like a bullseye on your crotch. It's as puzzling as it sounds. I followed another reviewer's lead and snipped mine off immediately. Pro tip: Keep nail clippers handy for this DIY upgrade.

Durability is hit or miss. After 20+ washes, mine are holding up well, but I did notice some thinning near the seams when held against bright light. Not a dealbreaker, but don't expect decade-long endurance.

Color roulette warning! My 'black and grey' pack arrived looking like a rejected Easter egg dye job – think mint green and baby blue stripes. If you're particular about colors, buy in-store where you can see them.

The ultimate test? I bought a second pack after testing the first. Despite the quirks, they're still the most breathable, no-fuss boxers I've found under $20. Just go in knowing you might need to perform minor surgery on that awkward button situation.