Let me start by saying the colors? Absolutely stunning. I've been using the 'Dawn' shade daily – it's this perfect rosy nude that makes my eyes look awake even when I'm running on 3 hours of sleep. The cream-to-powder formula blends like a dream with just my fingertips, and it stays put through my 10-hour workdays.

The convenience factor is unreal. I keep one in my purse for touch-ups, and the twist-up mechanism means no sharpening mess. It's become my go-to for those 'I overslept but still want to look polished' mornings – swipe, blend, and out the door in 30 seconds.

BUT (and this is a big but)... quality control seems to be an issue. Two of my four sticks completely detached from the base within weeks. Imagine opening your purse to find your favorite shadow smeared everywhere because the product fell out of its tube! At this price point ($24 per stick), I expected better construction.

Final verdict? When they work, they're magical. But until Lune+Aster fixes the packaging issues, I'd recommend being extra gentle with them or storing them upright at all times.