Just got this YTD polo shirt and here's my honest take after wearing it for a week!

The Good: The fabric is SO soft - that 95% cotton/5% spandex blend feels amazing against skin. Washed it twice already and no shrinkage or fading (got the navy blue one). Love the mock neck design - makes it look dressier than a regular polo.

Sizing Note: Listen to other reviewers - size up! I'm usually medium (5'11", 170lbs) but got large. Perfect fit after washing. The slim cut is flattering without being tight, though my gym buddy said the arms were weirdly baggy on him.

Versatility: Wore it to casual Friday at work with chinos and got compliments. Also great for weekend brunches with jeans. The quarter-zip adds nice detail without being fussy.

The Meh: It's definitely more t-shirt than traditional polo thickness. Fine for spring/summer but might need layering in cooler weather. Also, that collar stands up a bit too tall - can't fold it down properly.

For the price? Solid 8/10. Already ordered another in grey!