When my friend insisted I buy 'I Think I Don't Remember', they promised it would be hilarious. But honestly? It felt like digging up an old meme that just doesn't hit the same anymore.

The first time I opened it, I did crack a smile - there's something charmingly self-aware about the title itself. But after showing it to three different friends, we all had the same reaction: 'Oh... that's it?' The humor feels trapped in a very specific moment that's passed.

What surprised me was how often I actually reached for it when friends came over - not because it was funny, but because it became this weird conversation starter about how humor evolves. In that way, it accidentally became more interesting as a cultural artifact than as an actual joke product.

If you're looking for something to spark nostalgia about early internet humor, maybe. But if you want actual laughs? There are better options out there now.