Let me start by saying these pajamas are ADORABLE. The prints are super cute, and the footed design is perfect for keeping those tiny toes warm. My little one looked like a snuggle bug in them!
However, the sizing is where things get tricky. I ordered the 18-24 month size for my 1-year-old, and they fit more like 12-18 months. They were pretty snug on him, especially around the thighs. If your baby is on the chunkier side or close to the upper end of the size range, I'd definitely recommend sizing up.
The fabric is thinner than I expected - great for warmer climates or hot sleepers (my son runs warm too!), but not ideal if you're looking for something thick and cozy for winter nights. One mom mentioned her son's 'thunder thighs' split a seam - hilarious but also something to keep in mind!
A minor annoyance: the zipper only goes up, not down. This means fully unzipping for diaper changes instead of just unzipping from the bottom. Not a dealbreaker, but definitely less convenient than other brands.
After washing, some colors did fade a bit, which was disappointing considering Gerber's usually great quality. They held up okay though - no major shrinkage or tears despite my little crawler doing his thing in them.
Final verdict? These are decent budget-friendly PJs with cute designs, perfect for warmer nights or babies who run hot. Just be mindful of sizing issues and don't expect heavyweight warmth.