First impressions? This cake topper set is adorable and definitely adds a festive touch to any birthday cake. The black acrylic 'Happy Birthday' sign has a sleek, modern look that pairs well with various cake designs.

The stars are cute but require assembly - they don't come pre-attached. The package includes sticky dots, but some users reported stars falling off during shipping. Pro tip: keep some double-sided tape handy just in case!

Size-wise, it's perfect for small to medium cakes (about 4 inches wide). The acrylic isn't super thick, but it gets the job done for one-time use. Some users reported receiving scratched pieces, so inspect yours upon arrival.

Where this set really shines is its versatility. I used it for a moody gothic birthday cake and it looked fantastic! The silver stars added just the right amount of sparkle without being overwhelming.

Final verdict? Great value for the price if you don't mind a little DIY assembly. Just manage your expectations about the star attachments and you'll have a stylish cake decoration that's perfect for Instagram-worthy birthday moments!