First off, if you're still getting familiar with the base game, hold off on this expansion. But once you're craving more depth, Nature Incarnate is a game-changer.

The eight new spirits are brilliantly designed—no filler here. Each one feels unique, with mechanics like Incarna tokens adding fresh tactical layers. My favorite? The way they interact with the board—it’s like the island itself is alive.

The Habsburg Mining Colony adversary is ruthless. We lost our first two games, but the challenge made victory sweeter. The new scenarios? Perfect for players who think they’ve mastered everything.

Storage-wise, it’s well-organized (plenty of bags!), though the packaging could be greener. But with this much content, it’s hard to complain. Pro tip: Try the spirit aspects—they reinvent older spirits you might’ve overlooked.

At full price, it’s steep for an expansion, but when discounted? Absolutely worth it. Our game nights now revolve around which new spirit or variant to try next.