Let me start by saying this jacket is a STEAL for the price. I bought the floral print for my 8-year-old daughter, and she hasn't taken it off since it arrived. The colors are vibrant (though some reviewers note they're brighter than pictured), and the quality punches way above its weight class.

The water-resistant feature is legit - we've tested it in light rain and snow flurries. While it's not a heavy winter coat (don't expect it to handle sub-zero temps), it's perfect for 30-50°F weather. The quilted insulation provides just enough warmth without bulk, making it car-seat friendly - a huge plus for parents.

Pro tip: SIZE UP! We normally buy size L (10/12) but went with XL based on reviews, and it was the right call. The fit is slightly slim (the boys' version runs roomier), but the larger size allows for layering over hoodies. The sleeves run long - great for growing kids but might bunch slightly at the wrists initially.

The packable feature is genius. It stuffs into its own drawstring pouch (included!), making it perfect for travel or stashing in backpacks. My daughter loves showing off this "magic trick" to her friends.

After three months of playground use, sleepovers, and even a spaghetti incident, this jacket has held up remarkably well. The stitching remains intact, the zipper works smoothly, and the colors haven't faded. At under $20 (especially on sale), I don't stress about kid-induced wear and tear like I would with premium brands.

One minor gripe: The mock neck collar could be slightly taller for better wind protection. Also, while the pockets are cute, they're not deep enough to securely hold treasures like rocks or candy wrappers (ask me how I know).

Bottom line: This is our go-to transitional jacket that bridges fall through early winter beautifully. I'll definitely be buying again in the next size up - especially if I can catch another $11 sale!