Okay, so I finally caved and bought this waffle knit top after seeing it everywhere. Here's the real tea:

First off, the fabric feels like a cozy hug? Like seriously, it's so soft post-wash and hasn't pilled despite my cat's constant kneading (shoutout to my 7 furry quality testers). The V-neck is flattering without being too revealing, which is perfect for my teacher wardrobe.

BUT - sizing is whack. My lavender one from 2 years ago fits perfectly, but the new blue version arrived looking like I stole it from a basketball player. Same size tag, completely different dimensions. Pro tip: check those measurements like you're solving a math problem.

Also heads up - lighter colors might require a cami unless you're going for that 'see-through chic' look. My mauve one gets compliments though, especially when paired with jeans and ankle boots.

Washing has been dreamy (cold water + air dry crew represent), but some reviewers mentioned pilling issues. Mine's holding up, but I've only had it for a month. At this price point, I'll probably grab another in charcoal before they change the sizing again!